[Dmatz]

I have been at both. Boyd's is 9 miles closer, we did not like the proximity to our neighbors and felt it was very tight. We have been to blue water key several times. This is one our most favorite places. Always stayed water front with a dock. My boys 13,14 +,- went fishing, swimming from the dock. The Tiki huts were great for being outdoors. It's at mile marker 14 you should at a minimum go by and check it out. Bluewaterkey.com