[77newell]

There is a alternate consideration: does your wife like it? All the technical prowess in the world cannot compete with a wife's disapproval. If you are single there is no one else to please, just please yourself. You are focused on two great brands. If you choose a well cared for coach that your wife is happy with then I suspect everything will work out fine. And beware that just because a coach is newer does not mean it is in better shape, you have to check each one out.