Posts: 5,569
Threads: 261
Joined: Jul 2012
Dumb question. Do you have a tag axle?
Here is a sketch I made of Todd Flickema's setup.
Follow the lines for the concept.
Can you post a pic of your leveling valve switches?
So my logic is a bit muddled, but one valve misbehaving is a valve problem. Two valves misbehaving, in a symmetric fashion, is a wiring flumox or a switch in the wrong position.
Richard and Rhonda Entrekin
95 Newell, 390 Ex caretaker
99 Newell, 512 Ex caretaker
07 Prevost Marathon, 1025
Maverick Hybrid Toad
Inverness, FL (when we're home

)
(This post was last modified: 11-06-2019, 01:26 PM by
Richard.)
Posts: 86
Threads: 16
Joined: Apr 2019
Tom and Richard thanks for your responses and for the sketch of the air system. A couple of quick answers:
1. We do not have a tag axle. Our coach is 35' 2" completed in January 1984. No tag, no slides.
2. None of the MAC valves seemed to be magnetized at any time when I was testing them (always in travel mode during the tests). Will do more checking on that tomorrow (Thursday). Should at least some of them be magnetized when the Level Up or Down switches are engaged? I would think so.
3. The coach does air up in either mode, achieves travel height, and each corner will raise really high in level mode. I was shocked at how high it can go. When the engine is turned off (and the compressor goes off with it), the air bags stay inflated but the supply air system PSI falls to zero within a few minutes according to the dash board gauge.
In addition, I will post pictures of the leveling switches (top and bottom views) tomorrow. The leveling switches have been in the off positions during all the above testing. I do suspect a possible wiring screw up in some way as a result of the mobile mechanic and then us replacing the ignition switch. We are tracing down the various wires and circuits going from the ignition switch to the leveling switches and the various MAC and Skinner valves. We found that one wire (brown) seems to go from the ignition switch to the rear six pack and another wire (orange) goes from the ignition switch to the front six pack. Both wires are energized with the ignition switch in the on position and, when energized, the top MAC valves (front and rear) start venting air.
Also, while looking around yesterday Laureen and I confirmed the location of our engine mounted compressor (the only one we have), found our air dryer and saw the purge valve discharge several times while the compressor was cycling. We also discovered another air tank, this one mounted vertically near the rear axle, driver's side. We also found our two rear height control arms. So, we are slowly getting familiar with the air system and have watched Richard's videos several times, which has been enormously helpful.
Tom, I went to Clarke's blog and found photos he had posted of his coach's rear six pack that y'all replaced and that was helpful, especially the idea of taking a picture of everything before starting to dismantle and replace anything.
Glenn & Laureen Parker
Austin, Texas
1984 Newell 35' (Coach #58? - not confirmed)
6v92 TA Detroit Diesel, MT654 Allison 5 speed trans
2005 Honda Element toad
2007 Honda S2000 fun car
Posts: 5,569
Threads: 261
Joined: Jul 2012
“The coach does air up in either mode”. Would you define mode? Do you mean travel or level?
Good idea on checking which valves are energized.
Here are the very basics. In travel mode, with ignition on, the travel solenoids should be energized. No other.
In level mode, with no switches activated, no solenoids should be energized. If the raise/up switch is activated then the UP solenoids should be energized, And likewise for down.
The reason the airbags do not leak down with the supply pressure is that all solenoids (pathways to the airbags) are deenergized with the coach in off position.
Call me sometime when you are at the coach. 817 223 2056. Actually text me first, I get a lot of spam calls from Texas, and I don’t answer.
Richard and Rhonda Entrekin
95 Newell, 390 Ex caretaker
99 Newell, 512 Ex caretaker
07 Prevost Marathon, 1025
Maverick Hybrid Toad
Inverness, FL (when we're home

)
Posts: 5,569
Threads: 261
Joined: Jul 2012
Sorry for SWAG questions.
There is an air line coming off the supply tee, that goes through a skinner valve feeding the big regulator. Where does the air line coming out of the regulator go? What does that regulated air line feed?
It appears that skinner valves have been added to the two DOWN Mac valves. I am trying to figure out why they are needed. Are the Down Mac valves still wired up? Are they wired in parallel with the skinners? I am just wondering if someone added the skinners to the Mac valves.
Richard and Rhonda Entrekin
95 Newell, 390 Ex caretaker
99 Newell, 512 Ex caretaker
07 Prevost Marathon, 1025
Maverick Hybrid Toad
Inverness, FL (when we're home

)
Posts: 30
Threads: 0
Joined: Oct 2012
The skinner valves are normally closed valves to keep air from bleeding back thru the mac valves and skinner valves will only be energized when the ignition is on. The mac valves were good valves but leaked thru the valve all the time the N/C skinner valves eliminated the air leaks when not in use.
I would check all the wiring especially the grounds on all the valves. There is a ground connection at the bottom of the panel, but the one at the top isn't a good ground. All those grounds are daisy chained together and if you lose connection on one it could be effecting several valves. I would run the upper ground wires down to bolt to the lower ground stud.
Good luck!
Posts: 86
Threads: 16
Joined: Apr 2019
Very helpful info, Jimg. Thank you. Our Skinners are off with the ignition off and are on (magnetized) when the ignition is on. Will check the ground situation the next time we go out to the coach. It was cold and rainy in Austin this afternoon so we did not get out there.
Glenn & Laureen Parker
Austin, Texas
1984 Newell 35' (Coach #58? - not confirmed)
6v92 TA Detroit Diesel, MT654 Allison 5 speed trans
2005 Honda Element toad
2007 Honda S2000 fun car
Posts: 5,569
Threads: 261
Joined: Jul 2012
There is a clue here, just don’t know exactly how it could be happening. Jim, Clarke or Guy may be able to help.
First, if the purpose of the Skinnners is to provided a backup to the Mac valves leaking, then the Mac valves that the Skinnners are attached to are definitely the DOWN valves. If wired and functioning correctly the only time those Skinners should be magnetized is if the Down switch is activated.
Second, can one of the owners of this vintage coach explain the basic layout and function of the switches?
Specifically, is there a switch that toggles between level and travel?
Does the ignition on, override that switch and force the system into travel?
Is there an ALL down or ALL up switch for lowering and raising the coach?
Never mind my questions, I found the picture you posted when noodling the mystery switch in the drivers compartment.
Ok, cranking up my Conspriatron 5000, is it possible that the ignition switch rewire and this issue are related. Did you ever notice this before the switch issue? If not, is it possible that during the ignition switch wiring that you either wired something incorrectly in the powering of the leveling system OR something wasn’t working (like the mystery switch) because it didn’t have power and now it does.
Richard and Rhonda Entrekin
95 Newell, 390 Ex caretaker
99 Newell, 512 Ex caretaker
07 Prevost Marathon, 1025
Maverick Hybrid Toad
Inverness, FL (when we're home

)
(This post was last modified: 11-08-2019, 05:38 AM by
Richard.)
Posts: 86
Threads: 16
Joined: Apr 2019
Richard and Dave, thanks for the input and Dave, thanks for your diagram and photo. Your diagram seems to match my general layout. I found it especially interesting to see that you have no MAC valves and only what I call Skinner valves. I think in my system the Skinner valves are used as one way valves in association with the 4 down valves and the air pressure regulator in the back 6 pack manifold.
Richard, that mystery switch near my leveling switches in my center console seems totally unrelated to the air system. I think it is related to an electromagnetic lock system that a previous owner installed on the access panel over my generator bay in the front of the coach. The wires are the same color (purple and yellow). It is supposed to be a push and release system but doesn't work right now.
Also Richard I am holding in reserve your invitation to give you a call until Laureen and I have actually tried a few things and can ask questions from a more informed position. We appreciate your offer very much.
After a month of beating this stuff to death and over analyzing everything, Laureen and I have a developed a few theories of what we can do next. We will start by replacing one down MAC valve in the next few days that we think has a significant leaking port. I anticipate a significant reduction in the air leaks after that. If so, we will replace the other 3 down MAC valves, which I think are also leaking to a lesser degree because of similar problems. Next we will replace a 5th MAC valve that has a definite air leak (bubbles) because of a leak in the casing (not a port). We may end up replacing all the MAC valves at once as they are not too expensive. I will post an update when we stop speculating and actually get something done.
Glenn & Laureen Parker
Austin, Texas
1984 Newell 35' (Coach #58? - not confirmed)
6v92 TA Detroit Diesel, MT654 Allison 5 speed trans
2005 Honda Element toad
2007 Honda S2000 fun car
Posts: 5,569
Threads: 261
Joined: Jul 2012
At the risk of just restating the excellent input you have gotten from others, let me take a stab at what I would do in this situation.
Refurbishing the system with new valves is a worthwhile endeavor if you plan on keeping the coach. I would much rather work on stuff while I am at home, than in the middle of Wyoming.
I would take the approach of dividing the problem into two areas, electrical and solenoid valves.
The first thing I would do is ensure that the valves are wired correctly and the switches are doing what you think they should do. It’s a plain and simple exercise to have one person activate a switch and the other read the volt meter. Use a label maker and label the wires once you have confirmed they have power when they are supposed to. I like leads for the voltmeter with alligator clips on the end so I don’t have to fiddle with holding the leads on the wires. Also while going to this effort, check every pair for power when you activate each switch. It’s extra effort but you will protect yourself from unexpected wiring anomalies.
Only after confirming proper electrical function would I replace the MAC valves. The skinner valves are a band aid I think, and I would think very hard about using the MAC valve and skinner valve in series. You need one or the other, not both.
When I wired the new MAC valves in, I would use the watertight butt connectors, and hit them with the heat gun to seal them up.
Make a map of the system to add to your coach documentation.
Richard and Rhonda Entrekin
95 Newell, 390 Ex caretaker
99 Newell, 512 Ex caretaker
07 Prevost Marathon, 1025
Maverick Hybrid Toad
Inverness, FL (when we're home

)
(This post was last modified: 11-09-2019, 10:46 AM by
Richard.)