02-28-2024, 01:43 PM
Dave,
I base my comments on three pieces of data. The first is I saw a failed 20k hitch on a Newell pulling a stacker. The person had installed a commercially available wheeled device between the stacker and the coach in order to reduce the hitch weight of the stacker. When looking closely at the weld failure with the hitch supports attach to the engine subframe, it was very clear the weld failed from side forces. When you look at the vertical supports that the hitch is attached onto, there is NOTHING to resist side force. Some gussets would help tremendously.
The other two data points, both Newell, were failed tow vehicle base plate failures. Both obviously failed from side forces. Both were raised Jeeps with oversize tires.
My generic conclusion is that the exaggerated tail swing driven by the steerable tag, puts a sideways force in low speed maneuvers that may not have been considered in the original design.
This is my opinion, and I am just suggesting that one should at least be aware of the potential.
I base my comments on three pieces of data. The first is I saw a failed 20k hitch on a Newell pulling a stacker. The person had installed a commercially available wheeled device between the stacker and the coach in order to reduce the hitch weight of the stacker. When looking closely at the weld failure with the hitch supports attach to the engine subframe, it was very clear the weld failed from side forces. When you look at the vertical supports that the hitch is attached onto, there is NOTHING to resist side force. Some gussets would help tremendously.
The other two data points, both Newell, were failed tow vehicle base plate failures. Both obviously failed from side forces. Both were raised Jeeps with oversize tires.
My generic conclusion is that the exaggerated tail swing driven by the steerable tag, puts a sideways force in low speed maneuvers that may not have been considered in the original design.
This is my opinion, and I am just suggesting that one should at least be aware of the potential.
Richard and Rhonda Entrekin
95 Newell, 390 Ex caretaker
99 Newell, 512 Ex caretaker
07 Prevost Marathon, 1025
Maverick Hybrid Toad
Inverness, FL (when we're home
